unveiling the truth a detailed investigation Into The Ocean Gate submarine tragedy the Titan and Ocean Gate submersible mysteriously vanished on June 18 2023 an international North Atlantic ocean waters near Newfoundland Canada Stockton Rush the founder and CEO of Ocean Gate was one of five persons aboard the submerged vehicle which was on a tour of the RMS Titanic's wreckage since they had enough oxygen for three days the U.S Coast Guard and its Canadian counterparts initiated a significant search and rescue operation
parts of the sunken ship surfaced on June 22nd revealing the heartbreaking reality the submarine had collapsed under ocean pressure with no survivors this incident greatly upset everyone especially considering the compromised safety measures today we will delve into the details to understand what happened Ocean Gate history a brief overview let's start with what we know about Ocean Gate incorporation the company that ran the Titan submarine the Everett washington-based company is privately owned and sells basic submersibles for
research and exploration in the tourism industry in 2009 Guillermo Solan and Stockton Rush founded the business Rush aspiring to be an astronaut got his commercial pilot's license but was unable to fulfill his dream of becoming a military pilot due to his weak eyesight he later relocated to Seattle from San Francisco and began working at McDonnell Douglas as a flight test engineer for the F-15 Eagle Russia's passion for space travel changed to one of underwater exploration as he sought an exploratory experience
like Captain Kirk's aboard the Enterprise Rush married Wendy Rush whose ancestors Isidore and Ida Strauss sadly perished in the Titanic disaster we arrive at the current story due to this specific relationship to the Titanic The Unlucky incident happened during a deep-sea tourism Mission intended to investigate the Titanic's remains which sank in the North Atlantic in 1912. it's important to understand the challenges of deep sea exploration before diving into the intricacies of this catastrophe
the challenges of deep sea exploration deep sea exploration is superior to Aviation and space travel since they can defy gravity and move through the air but due to the tremendous pressure they must withstand deep sea Vehicles provide an even bigger engineering challenge the air column extends to the farthest regions of space where the air pressure is felt to be 14.7 pounds per square inch the pressure Rises by one atmosphere 14.7 PSI for every 10 meters 32.8 feet of depth as water is denser than air
the Titanic rests over 12 500 feet deep in the sea with its broken bow and Stern separated by over 2 600 feet among the debris this underwater wreckage which has been there for over a century can be found 400 miles off the coast of Newfoundland Canada to grasp the immense depth picture yourself lying down with a small board on your chest at 100 meters deep similar to the length of a soccer field the pressure is 10 atmospheres or 145 PSI the board would bear a force equivalent to 20 880 pounds similar to 4.7 Tesla
Model wise at 381 meters 1250 feet akin to the Empire State building's height the pressure skyrockets to 37.4 atmospheres and the weight on the board reaches a staggering 80 000 pounds the U.S Navy Sea class submarine at its maximum dive depth of 490 meters faces 48.5 atmospheres with the board burdened by 94 800 pounds finally at 828 meters the height of the Burj Khalifa the pressure soars to 82 atmospheres and the weight on the board becomes an astonishing 173 520 pounds at a depth of 3800 meters and 376
atmospheres of pressure the Titanic wreckage is submerged nearly 797 000 pounds would be supported by the board on your chest while James Cameron and the deep sea Challenger broke the record for deepest dive in 2012. the Ocean Gate Titan can only descend to about 4 000 meters the deep sea Challenger descended to the lowest point on Earth at 11 000 meters 36 000 feet the Mariana trench's deepest point the board on your chest would be weighed 2.3 million pounds at this enormous pressure of 1090 atmospheres
comparatively the pressure difference inside and outside an airplane at a cruising altitude of 36 000 feet is just between 7 and 9 PSI this puts into perspective why more people have ventured into space than the deepest parts of our oceans now let's discuss the numerous warning signs that surrounded Ocean Gate warning signs surrounding Ocean Gate the name Ocean Gate hints at tragedy from the beginning to prevent unauthorized access the Titans hatch was designed to be externally locked with 17 to 18 bolts
while protecting water seals in deep sea vessels as a legitimate design consideration it also emphasizes the critical need for safety precautions and backup systems one such safety measure could be an explosive cord that in an emergency could be deployed to forcefully open the hatch if the craft resurfaces but is not seen the Titan lacked GPS or navigational instruments including a Locator Beacon unlike most submarines it relied solely on data from the surface support vessel for navigation instead of employing GPS dead
reckoning gyro Compass speed measurements and ocean current estimates in 2019 ocean Gate's blog post defended why the Titan lacked Maritime certification raising concerns they argued that most accidents stem from operator error not mechanical failure suggesting that certification focuses solely on the vessel's physical state disregarding the company's commitment to operational safety however this explanation appeared unconvincing to many in 2022 journalist David Pogue joined the Titan to explore
the Titanic during the trip the surface support vessel lost track of the Titan for four to five hours the need for a Locator Beacon was discussed as they had no idea where the sub was they could still exchange brief text messages with the sub but its location remained unknown to maintain secrecy they disabled the ship's internet to prevent passengers from tweeting about the situation furthermore the Titan was controlled using a video game controller which seemed inappropriate given the seriousness of the operation
military-grade products undergo rigorous testing for safe operation for instance Apple's Vision Pro headset priced at 3 500 is considered inexpensive compared to the stringent standards of military-grade equipment the history of the Titan submersible the helmet made specifically for the F-35 combat plane costs four hundred thousand dollars its high cost is due to its limited production and rigorous testing extensive vibration testing on the helmet ensures the welds are strong at high altitudes of 40 to 50 000 feet it
is also tested for radium resistance and its high reliability is assured Ocean Gate initially bought antipodes in 2012 and used it as a Titan test site they received Priceless instruction and information from it they received assistance from the University of Washington's Applied Physics laboratory When developing their future project cyclops one although it was far from the Titanic's depths and had a maximum depth of only 500 meters it was a step towards their ultimate goal early versions of the
submersible had a carbon fiber Hull and were designed to dive vertically with swivel chairs to keep occupants upright on the first design analysis Boeing allegedly worked with Ocean Gate in the University of Washington but more study of this component of the story is necessary the final iteration of Ocean Gate submersible the Titan had a remarkable depth capability of 4000 meters one standout feature was its Hull constructed using a combination of carbon fiber and titanium sophisticated materials and engineering
carbon fiber remains relatively uncommon compared to traditional materials like high-strength steel and aluminum it is rarely found in most cars except for very high-end supercars similarly carbon fiber has only recently been incorporated into the aviation industry as seen in the Boeing Dreamliner with aluminum and titanium being the preferred choices for their well-known properties working with carbon fiber poses a distinct challenge due to limited knowledge and the need for precise Manufacturing concerns and red flags
raised Spencer Composites built hulls for Ocean Gate and Steve Fawcett's deep flight Challenger virgin Oceanic acquired the Challenger but its single dive design limited its use the Challenger's strength diminished with each dive peaking on the first it was originally intended for a record-setting dive in Smithsonian exhibition the concept of an operational lifetime is crucial and relevant to the Titan situation ocean Gate's website was deactivated on June 22nd the University of Washington's
Applied Physics laboratory denied involvement in the Titans design engineering or testing Boeing and NASA also confirmed no partnership or contribution to the Titan project these Revelations cast doubt on Ocean Gates claim Partnerships and affiliations suggesting a desire to enhance credibility through famous associations David lockridge's quality control report in January 2018 David Lockridge director of marine operations at Ocean Gate revealed the absence of a non-destructive investigation ndi for
the carbon fiber Hull which could compromise its strength the vessel's acrylic window was only rated for 1 300 meters not four thousand meters Lockridge was dismissed after persistently expressing his concerns and demanding a hull scan in June Ocean Gate sued Lockridge for improper disclosure and Fabrication of dismissal reasons the case was settled in November 2018 under confidential conditions leaving us with little information communication problems and incidents during a dive Beyond 10 000 feet on
December 10 2018 Stockton Rush encountered unexpected positive buoyancy requiring thrusters to counteract it this interfered with communication causing a one-hour loss of contact Rush declared himself the second person to solo dive to 13 000 feet after James Cameron in January 2020 the Titans Hull showed fatigue lowering its safe depth to 3000 meters it was repaired and re-rated for Dives up to 4000 meters the importance of understanding risks and exploration this video was created because we are entering a new era of
exotic tourism and exploration from space travel to deep sea diving we stand at the threshold of a wave of new explorations wealthier individuals like those involved in this incident are driven by the Allure of the next big thing however it's important to understand the risks as we venture into Uncharted territories compared to commercial Aviation with stringent regulatory oversight this new domain lacks such control Waters where these activities often take place have limited regulations while the parent vessel was registered
much of what happens in open Waters remain largely in regulating operational lifespan and material considerations aircraft benefit from rigorous testing and safety measures but exploration in this new era lacks the same level of scrutiny implosions at Great depths can be instantly fatal due to extreme pressure the Titan's operational lifetime was uncertain due to a lack of non-destructive tests on carbon fiber New Frontiers like space tourism lack established guidelines vessels built for deep sea pressures face unknown factors
and may experience deformation over time they should have a limited lifespan the cost of deep sea exploration ticket prices originally starting at 125 000 and later doubling should have been much higher possibly around a million dollars this would have allowed for regular vessel Replacements and thorough testing however cost cutting measures were likely taken to make its affordable resulting in insufficient risk understanding Lessons Learned and the path forward it's tragic but there was no rescue or lesson learned without loss
of life Engineers must learn from mistakes and prioritize safety awareness future deep sea exploration will likely require more costly and improved methodologies
0 Comments
Post a Comment